The EvalScribe Teacher Evaluation Blog — AI, Frameworks, & Observation Tips

Illinois Just Drew the Line on AI in Teacher Evaluations — and Left the Paperwork On the Right Side of It

Illinois Just Drew the Line on AI in Teacher Evaluations — and Left the Paperwork On the Right Side of Itby: Anthony D. Neely, Ph.D.Published on: 23/07/2026

Illinois SB 2909 (Public Act 104-0565) is the first US law on AI in teacher evaluation. What it actually says: AI can't assign the score or rating, but may support the administrative write-up. Teachers are covered too. Effective Jan 1, 2027.

Illinois Just Drew the Line on AI in Teacher Evaluations — and Left the Paperwork On the Right Side of It

Are AI Teacher Evaluations Defensible?

Are AI Teacher Evaluations Defensible?by: Anthony D. Neely, Ph.D.Published on: 29/05/2026

Whether an AI-assisted teacher evaluation holds up depends on the process, not the AI itself. The four properties that make any evaluation defensible, where AI helps, where it adds risk, and what to ask before it reaches a personnel file.

Are AI Teacher Evaluations Defensible?